After receiving a note back from one of the Commissioners suggesting that this newly proposed Urban Growth Boundary (UGB) Ordinance would only affect areas that “will be in the city limits”, and that it is intended to deal with only a few people with animals that disregard their neighbors, I thought it necessary to respond.
On a positive note, the letter above ended with the suggestion that it “will only take affect on the 3rd true complaint and even that will only require a management plan.” So in essence, there’s no enforcement power? My response below:
Dear Commissioners -
The Urban Growth Boundary is not within city limits at this time. In fact, the UGB (and this proposed ordinance) does not include properties within city limits. It does, however, include more than 2500 acres of rural land, spanning miles beyond the city limits of several city centers (http://www.clark.wa.gov/longrangeplan/review/). You can also view a map here: http://www.clark.wa.gov/topics/tdragzon.pdf
Where the intent may be to control those who create odor problems, it actually threatens all farmers, 4H'ers, and other homesteaders. Keep in mind the fees (vague, and without a limit on dollar amount), as well as additional permits needed for housing that is currently not required by law (agriculture buildings exempt - pdf attached below)... It's not just 'a management plan' for those who create havoc - it burdens all animal owners.
Also remember that many animals reproduce annually. "New animals" could essentially be an entire herd within a 3 year span. So, slowly and steadily, every animal on a plot would be accounted for and would abide by this new ordinance, not just 'new' farms. Our current farmers are in no way protected.
There are other methods that neighbors with poor animal husbandry could be squelched, including nuisance claims, Department of Animal Control & Health, Clean Water Act, Department of Ecology, etc... So the intent of this law essentially doubles up on other ways the County could manage these people/issues.
So why the necessity of this new ordinance that essentially hurts agriculture in Clark County? I imagine there is a genuine need. I'm just not sure I'm getting it. If it's primarily an odor issue, please address that - and only that.
With the many development projects on the slate, I feel that this may essentially ease the county's opportunity to annex farmers that otherwise would have had some freedom to grow. This is a clear and obvious threat to farmers. I hope I'm wrong.
If I'm wrong, I expect the Commissioners to listen to the voices of hundreds of people (see online petition) that oppose this proposed ordinance, that seemingly repeats existing restrictions in many ways, and directly hinders (not supports) agriculture. Please consider these things.