The public meeting regarding the proposed Urban Growth Boundary meeting was well attended, with a room packed (I didn’t do a head count, but I’d guess over a hundred). There were no seats remaining. The petition more than 350 e-signatures, with another hundred or more ‘real’ signatures (read the feedback and petition here). More than 1 1/2 hours of discussion cut short, including my excerpts from letter. thanks to Stuart.
Glenn Grossman reported on the meeting here. There were some very interesting points made during the public discussion time. There was over an hour and a half worth of public comment before the Commissioners needed to cut the meeting short. In fact, I hadn’t had the opportunity yet, and by Steve Stuart’s kindness, I was able to slip in and share a few excerpts from the letters that I had sent out, mainly addressing the future of farming, and how I have high hopes that my children will have fair opportunity to feasibly continue farming, if they so choose.
I did note that during the discussion time, each ‘public opinion’ got a rebuttal from the Commissioners, or from Gordy Euler. I’m not sure that was appropriate, considering this was ‘public opinion’ time, not open debate -- but I’m not entirely sure it was not appropriate either, as we got to see a glimpse into what their considerations were. You can watch to the entire meeting here. There was also suggestion that certain “blogs” were causing confusion unnecessarily. There was clear frustration that the people were being actively involved in the interpretation of the proposed ordinance, and coming to their own conclusions. I think it’s imperative that people actually see all sides in order to make an educated opinion.
I was very pleased that the meeting was well attended (wow!), and I think that made a big statement. The Commissioners did desire to address the concerns, and so we’ll await a new draft, and will hopefully see as many folks at the next meeting set for October 6th meeting with the Commissioners.
Afterward, a few of us got to wind down at Lapellah’s, where we dined on glorious (and lots of local) foods -- thanks Mark! They only cook on fire - they even have a ‘cob oven’ of sorts in the corner. It’s not cob, but it looks a lot like the one we want to build! It’s very cool!
9/10/09 Update: There continues to be progress on changing this proposed ordinance. The Columbian has reported about it here. Read the comments on the article as well. For more information and a copy of the latest proposal, visit http://www.clark.wa.gov/longrangeplan/projects/ and click "urban livestock review."
Wednesday, July 22, 2009
Tuesday, July 14, 2009
Dear Commissioners II
After receiving a note back from one of the Commissioners suggesting that this newly proposed Urban Growth Boundary (UGB) Ordinance would only affect areas that “will be in the city limits”, and that it is intended to deal with only a few people with animals that disregard their neighbors, I thought it necessary to respond.
On a positive note, the letter above ended with the suggestion that it “will only take affect on the 3rd true complaint and even that will only require a management plan.” So in essence, there’s no enforcement power? My response below:
Dear Commissioners -
The Urban Growth Boundary is not within city limits at this time. In fact, the UGB (and this proposed ordinance) does not include properties within city limits. It does, however, include more than 2500 acres of rural land, spanning miles beyond the city limits of several city centers (http://www.clark.wa.gov/longrangeplan/review/). You can also view a map here: http://www.clark.wa.gov/topics/tdragzon.pdf
Where the intent may be to control those who create odor problems, it actually threatens all farmers, 4H'ers, and other homesteaders. Keep in mind the fees (vague, and without a limit on dollar amount), as well as additional permits needed for housing that is currently not required by law (agriculture buildings exempt - pdf attached below)... It's not just 'a management plan' for those who create havoc - it burdens all animal owners.
Also remember that many animals reproduce annually. "New animals" could essentially be an entire herd within a 3 year span. So, slowly and steadily, every animal on a plot would be accounted for and would abide by this new ordinance, not just 'new' farms. Our current farmers are in no way protected.
There are other methods that neighbors with poor animal husbandry could be squelched, including nuisance claims, Department of Animal Control & Health, Clean Water Act, Department of Ecology, etc... So the intent of this law essentially doubles up on other ways the County could manage these people/issues.
So why the necessity of this new ordinance that essentially hurts agriculture in Clark County? I imagine there is a genuine need. I'm just not sure I'm getting it. If it's primarily an odor issue, please address that - and only that.
With the many development projects on the slate, I feel that this may essentially ease the county's opportunity to annex farmers that otherwise would have had some freedom to grow. This is a clear and obvious threat to farmers. I hope I'm wrong.
If I'm wrong, I expect the Commissioners to listen to the voices of hundreds of people (see online petition) that oppose this proposed ordinance, that seemingly repeats existing restrictions in many ways, and directly hinders (not supports) agriculture. Please consider these things.
On a positive note, the letter above ended with the suggestion that it “will only take affect on the 3rd true complaint and even that will only require a management plan.” So in essence, there’s no enforcement power? My response below:
Dear Commissioners -
The Urban Growth Boundary is not within city limits at this time. In fact, the UGB (and this proposed ordinance) does not include properties within city limits. It does, however, include more than 2500 acres of rural land, spanning miles beyond the city limits of several city centers (http://www.clark.wa.gov/longrangeplan/review/). You can also view a map here: http://www.clark.wa.gov/topics/tdragzon.pdf
Where the intent may be to control those who create odor problems, it actually threatens all farmers, 4H'ers, and other homesteaders. Keep in mind the fees (vague, and without a limit on dollar amount), as well as additional permits needed for housing that is currently not required by law (agriculture buildings exempt - pdf attached below)... It's not just 'a management plan' for those who create havoc - it burdens all animal owners.
Also remember that many animals reproduce annually. "New animals" could essentially be an entire herd within a 3 year span. So, slowly and steadily, every animal on a plot would be accounted for and would abide by this new ordinance, not just 'new' farms. Our current farmers are in no way protected.
There are other methods that neighbors with poor animal husbandry could be squelched, including nuisance claims, Department of Animal Control & Health, Clean Water Act, Department of Ecology, etc... So the intent of this law essentially doubles up on other ways the County could manage these people/issues.
So why the necessity of this new ordinance that essentially hurts agriculture in Clark County? I imagine there is a genuine need. I'm just not sure I'm getting it. If it's primarily an odor issue, please address that - and only that.
With the many development projects on the slate, I feel that this may essentially ease the county's opportunity to annex farmers that otherwise would have had some freedom to grow. This is a clear and obvious threat to farmers. I hope I'm wrong.
If I'm wrong, I expect the Commissioners to listen to the voices of hundreds of people (see online petition) that oppose this proposed ordinance, that seemingly repeats existing restrictions in many ways, and directly hinders (not supports) agriculture. Please consider these things.
Sunday, July 12, 2009
Dear Commissioners I
Dear Commissioners -
The UGB ordinance is close to my heart, and I would love to discuss it a bit. I realize that I'm not a resident of Clark County, but any (especially local) government that is restricting or burdening farming, in my book, directly affects me. And I want to share my opinion with you. I would welcome interactive conversation with you all on this as well!
Please look over the Agriculture Preservation Strategies Report:
http://www.co.clark.wa.us/legacylands/AgriculturePreservationReport.html
Also at the Washington Right to Farm:
http://www.leg.wa.gov/pub/billinfo%5C2005-06%5CHtm%5CBill%20Reports%5CSenate%20Final%5C5962.FBR.htm
What is the point of either of these, if we are being pushed out of farming at a local level?
Farmers have an ongoing abundance of restrictions - many of which are nearly impossible to meet unless you're a cookie cutter farm -- and even then it's hard. We have many taxes, permits, licenses, and fees to deal with on a constant basis. We have nuisance laws, on-farm sales traffic laws, zoning issues, we have NAIS, we have intra- and interstate commerce issues to deal with. We have animal transport issues (illegal to cross any state line without complete vet transport papers per animal, etc), required vaccines, etc... If, as a farmer, we abide by any labeling (natural, organic, local, etc), we have a slew more limitations. We have fear of lawsuit or complaint. Needless to say, it's a hard job - and a continual battle. So I'm very, very leery of additional restrictions - and need to know that they are absolutely necessary, and not already covered under another 'law'.
As the city continues to grow, city-dwellers are reaching into farmland. This creates issues on many levels, and I can understand the need to have a clear respect for each other, as neighbors. But just as I cannot control their wishes to live a city life in the country, they should not be able to penalize my lifestyle because of their choice to move into a more rural area.
Several folks have asked me why I am working so hard spreading the word about this newly proposed Urban Growth Boundary (UGB) Ordinance in Clark County, since I don’t live in Clark County. It sort of blows me away that they’d assume I wouldn’t be an active part in this. Just because it’s not in my county doesn’t mean it doesn’t directly affect you or me. It affects farmers, and has the potential of setting precedence. And whether or not we’re all farming with the same methods or ideals, we are all traveling the same scraggly path of fighting for our land and food.
My biggest concern is that the wording of this ordinance is incredibly vague. It leaves massive room for discrimination against farmers. And as a Judge ruled not two months ago, "farming is dead" in Clark County. If this is our officials belief, then they clearly do not support farming in general, and yet there are more than a thousand (albeit mostly small) farms within the county. Many of which feed hundreds of families directly in the community. This, in my book, is a big deal. And they, like any farm, need to be protected and appreciated.
When chatting about the Clark County UBG with a group, one person said that it didn’t matter much, as small farmers aren’t “real farmers”. I beg to differ. And so does the USDA.
According to the USDA Agriculture Census in 2007, the average farmer is aging. The amount of American land used to farm is declining. This can be regarded as very disheartening news. Indeed, it IS very disheartening news to hear that our soils are being stripped from farmers for one reason or another – perhaps retirement, perhaps more land restrictions, often in the name of “green", or in this case, "urban growth". But the encouraging news is that small farms are blossoming everywhere. According to the same census, there are actually more farms than previously. Tho’ the amount of land has decreased to smaller parcels, there are more small diverse community farms directly feeding within communities (but with fewer packing plants or feed lots).
When considering new ordinances, rules, or regulations, it is crucial that we consider the people that they directly affect, which appears to be a mix of large parcels of ag, with small acreage being a significant part of farming these days as well. The diversity of farmers isn't about who is "real" and who is not, it's about who is doing their part to keep agriculture in our community, our state, and our country. It's about who is doing their job to be responsible land owners, and to keep soil in active use, with little damage to what we've been given. I feel like I should leave this little bit of land in better shape than I got it in, as I was gifted a beautiful thing. And that means protecting agriculture, small or large. That means standing up not just for the big guys, but for the little guys, too. They are doing their darndest to see that farming continues, even if they cannot maintain large pieces of land.
My biggest goal is that my children can do what we have the blessing of doing. My hope is that we do not restrict ourselves clean out of land, because I want them, unlike most city folk, to understand that food comes from dirt (and manure and roosters crowing - the good and the bad). And there's something incredibly satisfying and amazing in that on SO many levels. We must be the voices of the next generation of farming.
And so I do what I can to support any agriculture activity. And I do not think that this proposed ordinance supports farming (or the environment) in any way. It supports urban living (or sprawl). So until I see wording that can respect both parties, I just can't support it.
I hope that makes sense - and if we have the opportunity to discuss it more, I'd love to! I will see you at the public meeting on the 21st if we cannot meet sooner!
The UGB ordinance is close to my heart, and I would love to discuss it a bit. I realize that I'm not a resident of Clark County, but any (especially local) government that is restricting or burdening farming, in my book, directly affects me. And I want to share my opinion with you. I would welcome interactive conversation with you all on this as well!
Please look over the Agriculture Preservation Strategies Report:
http://www.co.clark.wa.us/legacylands/AgriculturePreservationReport.html
Also at the Washington Right to Farm:
http://www.leg.wa.gov/pub/billinfo%5C2005-06%5CHtm%5CBill%20Reports%5CSenate%20Final%5C5962.FBR.htm
What is the point of either of these, if we are being pushed out of farming at a local level?
Farmers have an ongoing abundance of restrictions - many of which are nearly impossible to meet unless you're a cookie cutter farm -- and even then it's hard. We have many taxes, permits, licenses, and fees to deal with on a constant basis. We have nuisance laws, on-farm sales traffic laws, zoning issues, we have NAIS, we have intra- and interstate commerce issues to deal with. We have animal transport issues (illegal to cross any state line without complete vet transport papers per animal, etc), required vaccines, etc... If, as a farmer, we abide by any labeling (natural, organic, local, etc), we have a slew more limitations. We have fear of lawsuit or complaint. Needless to say, it's a hard job - and a continual battle. So I'm very, very leery of additional restrictions - and need to know that they are absolutely necessary, and not already covered under another 'law'.
As the city continues to grow, city-dwellers are reaching into farmland. This creates issues on many levels, and I can understand the need to have a clear respect for each other, as neighbors. But just as I cannot control their wishes to live a city life in the country, they should not be able to penalize my lifestyle because of their choice to move into a more rural area.
Several folks have asked me why I am working so hard spreading the word about this newly proposed Urban Growth Boundary (UGB) Ordinance in Clark County, since I don’t live in Clark County. It sort of blows me away that they’d assume I wouldn’t be an active part in this. Just because it’s not in my county doesn’t mean it doesn’t directly affect you or me. It affects farmers, and has the potential of setting precedence. And whether or not we’re all farming with the same methods or ideals, we are all traveling the same scraggly path of fighting for our land and food.
My biggest concern is that the wording of this ordinance is incredibly vague. It leaves massive room for discrimination against farmers. And as a Judge ruled not two months ago, "farming is dead" in Clark County. If this is our officials belief, then they clearly do not support farming in general, and yet there are more than a thousand (albeit mostly small) farms within the county. Many of which feed hundreds of families directly in the community. This, in my book, is a big deal. And they, like any farm, need to be protected and appreciated.
When chatting about the Clark County UBG with a group, one person said that it didn’t matter much, as small farmers aren’t “real farmers”. I beg to differ. And so does the USDA.
According to the USDA Agriculture Census in 2007, the average farmer is aging. The amount of American land used to farm is declining. This can be regarded as very disheartening news. Indeed, it IS very disheartening news to hear that our soils are being stripped from farmers for one reason or another – perhaps retirement, perhaps more land restrictions, often in the name of “green", or in this case, "urban growth". But the encouraging news is that small farms are blossoming everywhere. According to the same census, there are actually more farms than previously. Tho’ the amount of land has decreased to smaller parcels, there are more small diverse community farms directly feeding within communities (but with fewer packing plants or feed lots).
When considering new ordinances, rules, or regulations, it is crucial that we consider the people that they directly affect, which appears to be a mix of large parcels of ag, with small acreage being a significant part of farming these days as well. The diversity of farmers isn't about who is "real" and who is not, it's about who is doing their part to keep agriculture in our community, our state, and our country. It's about who is doing their job to be responsible land owners, and to keep soil in active use, with little damage to what we've been given. I feel like I should leave this little bit of land in better shape than I got it in, as I was gifted a beautiful thing. And that means protecting agriculture, small or large. That means standing up not just for the big guys, but for the little guys, too. They are doing their darndest to see that farming continues, even if they cannot maintain large pieces of land.
My biggest goal is that my children can do what we have the blessing of doing. My hope is that we do not restrict ourselves clean out of land, because I want them, unlike most city folk, to understand that food comes from dirt (and manure and roosters crowing - the good and the bad). And there's something incredibly satisfying and amazing in that on SO many levels. We must be the voices of the next generation of farming.
And so I do what I can to support any agriculture activity. And I do not think that this proposed ordinance supports farming (or the environment) in any way. It supports urban living (or sprawl). So until I see wording that can respect both parties, I just can't support it.
I hope that makes sense - and if we have the opportunity to discuss it more, I'd love to! I will see you at the public meeting on the 21st if we cannot meet sooner!
Friday, July 10, 2009
The Pits
I’ve spent my week canning cherry pie filling, maraschino cherries, and starting cherry liqueur (or extract) with pie cherries, and have dried over 10#’s of Bings and Rainiers. It’s all so very yummy!
When I first started out, I called Anne in a crunch, asking if she had a cherry pitter I could borrow. She said that she just did it the old fashioned way her Grandma did it, with a bobby pin. So I got out the “hair thing” box and went to work. It was amazing – just pop it in, and pop it out! The kids and I entertained ourselves for an entire afternoon of this. A couple of days later I was in the store and found a great sale on a pitter that has sped up the process a bit. The many boxes of cherries was a bit daunting, but has been nothing but sheer entertainment (and a whole lot of sticky fingers!).
Tho’ I add blog entries daily, they all seem to be on my head, and so alas, the poor website is getting to be a bit out of date. Perhaps winter is for blogging. Meanwhile, the swirl of activity is NOW, and so there is truly much to say!
One of the current issues that I’ve been working on is a new proposed ordinance in Clark County regarding their Urban Growth Boundary and livestock. You can read the ordinance itself here, as well as Glenn’s (a local food/farm activist) position here, as well as the petition to stop this from becoming an accepted new restriction.*
Where I can completely see the need to be respectful of each others neighbors, and possibly even of ways to control that as a county, I feel that more restrictions on small farmers is only inhibiting Clark’s participation in “going green”, so to speak. Clark has adamantly refused to accept that farming is, indeed, alive and well within the community, and continues to thwart the efforts who are trying to sustain their land, family, and community by practicing quality animal husbandry by threatening penalties of paperwork, fees, and permits.
In a critical time of economic recession, it seems only logical that those who help maintain our community (our leaders in politics and government) encourage families to be able to meet needs on their own. As budgets have been cut significantly, they do not have the resources to provide things like food and shelter to the hundreds and thousands who have lost their jobs. Why not prepare families to provide basic through newly appreciated ideas such as Victory Gardens?
This is not just about the urban backyard farmer, though. The Urban Growth Boundary spreads far and wide, with many people not even knowing that they are within it. Several of Clark’s biggest farms are within that space, as well as several dairies (or replacement herds). This creates huge issues to them in particular, in my opinion, as conventional (or mono-crop) farms often have a higher rate of air/ground/noise pollution.
I realize that cities are growing. I also realize that the majority of city dwellers have no idea where their food comes from, and simply do not understand how important it is that we have farms, in order to have food. We should be educating people about farming, not shunning farmers themselves. Where perhaps in the past generations farming has been viewed as a ‘dirty job’, people are beginning to realize that farming is what we live off of, and should be prized as an endangered specie.
I need to get a letter to the Commissioners. After I get the munchkins to bed, and the cherry juice off of my walls.
*This issue has also been picked up by an Olympia newspaper as well as the Capital Press
When I first started out, I called Anne in a crunch, asking if she had a cherry pitter I could borrow. She said that she just did it the old fashioned way her Grandma did it, with a bobby pin. So I got out the “hair thing” box and went to work. It was amazing – just pop it in, and pop it out! The kids and I entertained ourselves for an entire afternoon of this. A couple of days later I was in the store and found a great sale on a pitter that has sped up the process a bit. The many boxes of cherries was a bit daunting, but has been nothing but sheer entertainment (and a whole lot of sticky fingers!).
Tho’ I add blog entries daily, they all seem to be on my head, and so alas, the poor website is getting to be a bit out of date. Perhaps winter is for blogging. Meanwhile, the swirl of activity is NOW, and so there is truly much to say!
One of the current issues that I’ve been working on is a new proposed ordinance in Clark County regarding their Urban Growth Boundary and livestock. You can read the ordinance itself here, as well as Glenn’s (a local food/farm activist) position here, as well as the petition to stop this from becoming an accepted new restriction.*
Where I can completely see the need to be respectful of each others neighbors, and possibly even of ways to control that as a county, I feel that more restrictions on small farmers is only inhibiting Clark’s participation in “going green”, so to speak. Clark has adamantly refused to accept that farming is, indeed, alive and well within the community, and continues to thwart the efforts who are trying to sustain their land, family, and community by practicing quality animal husbandry by threatening penalties of paperwork, fees, and permits.
In a critical time of economic recession, it seems only logical that those who help maintain our community (our leaders in politics and government) encourage families to be able to meet needs on their own. As budgets have been cut significantly, they do not have the resources to provide things like food and shelter to the hundreds and thousands who have lost their jobs. Why not prepare families to provide basic through newly appreciated ideas such as Victory Gardens?
This is not just about the urban backyard farmer, though. The Urban Growth Boundary spreads far and wide, with many people not even knowing that they are within it. Several of Clark’s biggest farms are within that space, as well as several dairies (or replacement herds). This creates huge issues to them in particular, in my opinion, as conventional (or mono-crop) farms often have a higher rate of air/ground/noise pollution.
I realize that cities are growing. I also realize that the majority of city dwellers have no idea where their food comes from, and simply do not understand how important it is that we have farms, in order to have food. We should be educating people about farming, not shunning farmers themselves. Where perhaps in the past generations farming has been viewed as a ‘dirty job’, people are beginning to realize that farming is what we live off of, and should be prized as an endangered specie.
I need to get a letter to the Commissioners. After I get the munchkins to bed, and the cherry juice off of my walls.
*This issue has also been picked up by an Olympia newspaper as well as the Capital Press
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)