I think I ruffled a few feathers tonight at the Clark County Rural Task Force Meeting. I certainly didn’t mean to, but I think I may have.
I was invited to this meeting by one of the members, asking for a bit of an agriculture voice. As a “youngster” (and as I often do) I went in to the meeting with a positive attitude and the “next generation” frame-of-mind.
As the group debated their 20- and 40- plan, I heard discussion about “keeping at least 20 years of land for residential growth” (with a snarky comment from a farmer: “what about keeping at least 20 years of land for our food production?” - Kudo’s to that!). It got me thinking, and so I just had to think aloud when asked for public comment (sigh, I tend to do that, sometimes too often...).
Paraphrasing my part:
“Looking around this room, and no offense meant, the average age is around 45+. I’m wondering who is representing the next generation that will be active farmers and community members in twenty to forty years...”
Gordy Euler mutters, quite loudly (amidst his laughing out loud at my comments): “how old does she think we are?!” He and task force member Byron Woltersdorf enjoy a chuckle while I continue to address the group:
I continued: “...As a young mother who farms, I’d like to know that my kids can find land that is affordable & able to be farmed, if they choose, yet it seems that affordable farmland is disappearing...”
Dan Dupuis loudly interrupts: “Disappearing land? Isn’t that a clever trick! How do you do that?” And then begins to rebut my words.
I move ahead, cutting him short: “If you mean that we will be raising houses instead of food in the future, yes, it seems to be quite tricky. But please let me finish my three minutes of public comment time before you address my opinion...” Dan accepts, and Gordy jokingly cuts in: “Yeah, shut up, Dan!” Later Dan thanked me for cutting him off during my opportunity to speak.
After I was done explaining my concern, I was assured by one or two of the members that they were highly concerned for farmers, and when they talked of subdividing, rezoning, and downsizing, they often were simply playing devil’s advocate - not that they themselves were advocates of mass housing in the rural areas.
They spoke condescendingly as if I didn’t understand what was going on, or what any of this meant, and helped ‘fill in the blanks’ for me, reassuring me that they knew these issues well. They also reminded me that as a task force, they needed to consider the rights of property owners.*
I nodded approvingly. If they say they’re hoping to preserve farmland, I’m happy. So long as it’s true.
The fact is, Clark County is growing. I realize that future planning is an important part of city and county managing, and the change over the next twenty years will likely hurt current land owners in some way or another. I’m not sure what the fix is, but want to make sure that everything is considered while making these long-term decisions.
I would have liked to see the group made up of a more diverse age group, knowing that this will affect the next generation more than the current. I hope they will seek input from all that this will affect, and are not considering personal gain/loss as much as long-term viability. I wish the group my best. It is no doubt a hard committee to be on, as they are responsible to give a proposal that will ensure a solid future encompassing all of these things. That’s a lot of work, no doubt!
*Meaning the right to develop their own land. Of course, they don’t aren’t meaning a land owners right to continue farming.
Also remember that the average age in this room (that were chosen by Commissioner Marc Boldt) is near retirement, and their future plans with their own parcels may be to develop (so how much are they considering the big picture - rather than their personal gain/loss, which isn’t diverse in succession?). They don’t want to lock down land that may be their soon-to-be retirement fund.
I’ve blogged multiple times in the past year about how farmers are aging, and are selling for retirement, as their land is worth more (financially) for development than for agriculture. That said, I wonder if this group would actually want to solidify and preserve land that would not be able to be sold as an investment/retirement.
Tuesday, December 8, 2009
Saturday, December 5, 2009
Another Example
Today I found out that another fellow dairy farmer is struggling with the media. This is always disheartening for me to hear.
Dungeness Valley Creamery (DVC) has a 250-cow dairy in Sequim, Washington. They supply dozens of retail stores, co-ops, and buyers clubs with unpasteurized jersey cow milk. They are by far the largest raw dairy in Washington State, which currently has about two dozen licensed raw dairies. Down from 35+ some year and a half ago.*
It’s my understanding that someone in Clark County got sick with e. coli in November, and then, weeks later, 2 became sick nearer to Seattle with e. coli. Consequently, the Washington State Department of Agriculture came out with this (link) public statement, which the media ran with. The negative effect this has had is amazing, and seems littered with political jargone and manipulation. You’ll find a local article here, sprinkled with a skewed point of view, thus creating public confusion and biasedness. DVC, understanding the need to speak up, put out the following response on their website:
Dungeness Valley Creamery response to Washington State Department of Agriculture (WSDA) Press Release:
The Washington State Department of Agriculture (WSDA) issued a misleading press release involving our business, Dungeness Valley Creamery. The press release failed to mention that there has been no proven link between the illnesses and our milk. Two of the three e coli’s were not even e coli 0157: H7. Although they mention that they found no e coli in our current batch of milk, they fail to mention that e coli has never been found in any of our milk…ever. When they say that they found the same bacteria at Dungeness Valley Creamery that caused one of the illnesses, they fail to explain that they found it in one swab test out of hundreds in an old dried up cow patty in a field and was not tested to be a DNA match. The bottling room in the creamery, the farm where we house and milk the cows, and the milk itself has been tested clean over and over.
WSDA does mention that there are 100,000 illnesses of the 0157 H7 e coli strain every year in the US. It seems we only hear about the illnesses linked to raw milk. E coli can be found anywhere and everywhere. Why are these other cases being ignored and not released to the press? This is an excellent example of government bias against raw milk “When someone who drinks raw milk becomes ill, government agencies immediately report an ‘association’ with raw milk, ignoring other vectors of disease and subsequent tests showing the milk to be clean” says Sally Fallon, President of the Weston A. Price Foundation. We at Dungeness Valley Creamery sell about 250 gallons a day on average and so thousands of people have drank our milk for over three years now without any illnesses. We’ve had a very good relationship with the state and our inspector has been impressed with how easy we are to work with and how clean our facility is.
WSDA did not issue any recall and they have the power to do so. If they proved our milk was not safe, they would have recalled all of our milk immediately. There has been no recall and you are still able to purchase this most wholesome and tested clean product. WSDA only put out the press release to make sure they are covered and are erring on the side of caution.
We at the Dungeness Valley Creamery strive to provide the highest quality milk in its natural form. Our reputation has been compromised without any fault of our own. We are a hard working, God-fearing family farm trying to make an honest living. We thank all of our loyal customers and ask for your continued support and prayers.
(Reference: http://www.realmilk.com/press-release-12mar07.html)
Though some retail stores pulled DVC’s milk from their shelves upon WSDA’s Press release, linking the e. coli to their dairy, several have already restocked their shelves after understanding more of the story. Whole Foods has not allowed re-entry of DVC’s dairy into their stores.
Because of our own issues with the media’s (and other folks’) desire to shred reputations unfoundedly, I looked up a few things, and came up with a few points below. Before you completely jump to conclusions, consider there may be an alternative to what’s being publicized:
*The majority of all ruminants/cows have e. coli in their digestive tracts. (so yes, it WILL likely be found in cow patties) If ruminants are fed grains, they are more likely to shed e. coli. Feeding only grass can help hinder this shedding.
*NO e. coli (good or bad - there are different strains - some completely harmless - and even beneficial) was found in ANY milk from the dairy.
*NONE of the e.coli tested from this dairy was DNA matched to those who were sick (and only one was strain matched). There is NO scientific link or proof of connection.
*The ONLY link is that these people drank raw milk from this dairy, which led WSDA to publicly state that one of their licensed dairies was linked to this "outbreak”. WSDA, whose mission statement is to: "...serves the people of Washington by supporting the agricultural community..."**
*No milk was recalled. If WSDA believed this dairies milk to be harmful, it would be their obligation to put an immediate stop to consuming it. Clearly they do not think it poses a current risk, or is dangerous to the public.
*250 gallons were going out per day. IF e. coli 0157:H7 was in their milk (70 cows milked per day, mixed into a bulk tank, contaminating the entire batch, if so), the percentage of consumers who got sick from this deadly pathogen is tiny. (remember that all 3 got sick on different occasions, so they're not all from the same batch, and not all even had the same strain, it seems)
This whole onslaught of bad press toward this dairy wreaks of Big Ag. Yes, raw milk can be good for you. Some shouldn’t drink it perhaps. There is room for all types of farms - and I for one would love to see MORE, and am happy to find diversity, as a consumer.
This is very similar to the 2005 cases, as the Oregonian article suggested. False information being fed (check your facts - don’t believe everything you hear). Which may, in the end, be our final demise. Go ahead, think for yourself. And trust a farmer, not a third party.
I wish DVC the best. I know they can make their way out of this, and even grow because of it. The VOICE of agriculture is the FARMER. And people are starting to trust that alone more. Ironically, our own issues backfired and actually caused our business to boom. We’re thriving more than we may ever have. But it was a tough road. But a good lesson - that needs to be shared. Here’s to massively good things to DVC, and to their future of dairying!
*Among other reasons, my theory is that the biggest hardship for these farmers is liability insurance, which is now impossible to find. But you must have it in order to sell in stores, farmers markets, and even directly from the farm for those who wish to carry it.
**I do believe that WSDA’s intent is to keep our food safe. I know we, like DVC, have built a good working relationship with WSDA since 2006, and realize that they have a need to constantly protect consumers as well as farmers.
Dungeness Valley Creamery (DVC) has a 250-cow dairy in Sequim, Washington. They supply dozens of retail stores, co-ops, and buyers clubs with unpasteurized jersey cow milk. They are by far the largest raw dairy in Washington State, which currently has about two dozen licensed raw dairies. Down from 35+ some year and a half ago.*
It’s my understanding that someone in Clark County got sick with e. coli in November, and then, weeks later, 2 became sick nearer to Seattle with e. coli. Consequently, the Washington State Department of Agriculture came out with this (link) public statement, which the media ran with. The negative effect this has had is amazing, and seems littered with political jargone and manipulation. You’ll find a local article here, sprinkled with a skewed point of view, thus creating public confusion and biasedness. DVC, understanding the need to speak up, put out the following response on their website:
Dungeness Valley Creamery response to Washington State Department of Agriculture (WSDA) Press Release:
The Washington State Department of Agriculture (WSDA) issued a misleading press release involving our business, Dungeness Valley Creamery. The press release failed to mention that there has been no proven link between the illnesses and our milk. Two of the three e coli’s were not even e coli 0157: H7. Although they mention that they found no e coli in our current batch of milk, they fail to mention that e coli has never been found in any of our milk…ever. When they say that they found the same bacteria at Dungeness Valley Creamery that caused one of the illnesses, they fail to explain that they found it in one swab test out of hundreds in an old dried up cow patty in a field and was not tested to be a DNA match. The bottling room in the creamery, the farm where we house and milk the cows, and the milk itself has been tested clean over and over.
WSDA does mention that there are 100,000 illnesses of the 0157 H7 e coli strain every year in the US. It seems we only hear about the illnesses linked to raw milk. E coli can be found anywhere and everywhere. Why are these other cases being ignored and not released to the press? This is an excellent example of government bias against raw milk “When someone who drinks raw milk becomes ill, government agencies immediately report an ‘association’ with raw milk, ignoring other vectors of disease and subsequent tests showing the milk to be clean” says Sally Fallon, President of the Weston A. Price Foundation. We at Dungeness Valley Creamery sell about 250 gallons a day on average and so thousands of people have drank our milk for over three years now without any illnesses. We’ve had a very good relationship with the state and our inspector has been impressed with how easy we are to work with and how clean our facility is.
WSDA did not issue any recall and they have the power to do so. If they proved our milk was not safe, they would have recalled all of our milk immediately. There has been no recall and you are still able to purchase this most wholesome and tested clean product. WSDA only put out the press release to make sure they are covered and are erring on the side of caution.
We at the Dungeness Valley Creamery strive to provide the highest quality milk in its natural form. Our reputation has been compromised without any fault of our own. We are a hard working, God-fearing family farm trying to make an honest living. We thank all of our loyal customers and ask for your continued support and prayers.
(Reference: http://www.realmilk.com/press-release-12mar07.html)
Though some retail stores pulled DVC’s milk from their shelves upon WSDA’s Press release, linking the e. coli to their dairy, several have already restocked their shelves after understanding more of the story. Whole Foods has not allowed re-entry of DVC’s dairy into their stores.
Because of our own issues with the media’s (and other folks’) desire to shred reputations unfoundedly, I looked up a few things, and came up with a few points below. Before you completely jump to conclusions, consider there may be an alternative to what’s being publicized:
*The majority of all ruminants/cows have e. coli in their digestive tracts. (so yes, it WILL likely be found in cow patties) If ruminants are fed grains, they are more likely to shed e. coli. Feeding only grass can help hinder this shedding.
*NO e. coli (good or bad - there are different strains - some completely harmless - and even beneficial) was found in ANY milk from the dairy.
*NONE of the e.coli tested from this dairy was DNA matched to those who were sick (and only one was strain matched). There is NO scientific link or proof of connection.
*The ONLY link is that these people drank raw milk from this dairy, which led WSDA to publicly state that one of their licensed dairies was linked to this "outbreak”. WSDA, whose mission statement is to: "...serves the people of Washington by supporting the agricultural community..."**
*No milk was recalled. If WSDA believed this dairies milk to be harmful, it would be their obligation to put an immediate stop to consuming it. Clearly they do not think it poses a current risk, or is dangerous to the public.
*250 gallons were going out per day. IF e. coli 0157:H7 was in their milk (70 cows milked per day, mixed into a bulk tank, contaminating the entire batch, if so), the percentage of consumers who got sick from this deadly pathogen is tiny. (remember that all 3 got sick on different occasions, so they're not all from the same batch, and not all even had the same strain, it seems)
This whole onslaught of bad press toward this dairy wreaks of Big Ag. Yes, raw milk can be good for you. Some shouldn’t drink it perhaps. There is room for all types of farms - and I for one would love to see MORE, and am happy to find diversity, as a consumer.
This is very similar to the 2005 cases, as the Oregonian article suggested. False information being fed (check your facts - don’t believe everything you hear). Which may, in the end, be our final demise. Go ahead, think for yourself. And trust a farmer, not a third party.
I wish DVC the best. I know they can make their way out of this, and even grow because of it. The VOICE of agriculture is the FARMER. And people are starting to trust that alone more. Ironically, our own issues backfired and actually caused our business to boom. We’re thriving more than we may ever have. But it was a tough road. But a good lesson - that needs to be shared. Here’s to massively good things to DVC, and to their future of dairying!
*Among other reasons, my theory is that the biggest hardship for these farmers is liability insurance, which is now impossible to find. But you must have it in order to sell in stores, farmers markets, and even directly from the farm for those who wish to carry it.
**I do believe that WSDA’s intent is to keep our food safe. I know we, like DVC, have built a good working relationship with WSDA since 2006, and realize that they have a need to constantly protect consumers as well as farmers.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)